Pro’s and Con’s of using mechanical switches
What is wrong with using mechanical switches?
There is nothing bad about using mechanical switches as a True-Bypass in effects as long as you are aware of the drawbacks:
Drawbacks of using a mechanical switch:
- there is mechanical noise when pressing the switch (especially with some 3PDT models)
- good mechanical switches are rather expensive
- they require a good amount of pressure to activate
- they cannot be remote-controlled
So what is the solution to these drawbacks?
A good way to solve all of the above issues is to use a relay. Thats nothing more than a mechanical switch controlled by a magnetic field.
So its a mechanical switch again – why is it different? Its different because mechanical stomp switches are sturdy and large devices – just because you stomp on them. Relays can be much smaller and switch more accurate because there is not much mechanical impact to them. And they are controlled by an electronic circuit which allows a few fancy things to be done.
How does it work:
Looking at the switching-side we see that there are also two double-throw switches in the relay. So we have the same standard wiring here like we have in the standard wiring diagram for the mechanical switches.
On the left-hand-side there is a transistor in this circuit. If no positive signal is applied to the basis of the transistor the connection between collector and emitter is broken and nothing happens.
Once a positive signal (ca. 0.7V) is applied to the transistors basis it conducts and a current can flow through the collector to the basis. At this time the coil of the relay is generating a magnetic field that activates the armature and the switching side of the relay switches on. (There is also a spring bringing the armature back into its default position once the current is turned off again.)
So far this is all that is to it but what do the other components do? D1 is a protection diode which protects the rest of the circuit from a negative spike that occours when the magnetic field is shut down. The indicator LED and its current limiting resistor are connected parallel to the relay and are switched on together with the relay.
The above circuit is basically the same in all relay true-bypass circuits using a non-latching relay. But there is a very big difference to what actually switches the relay.